What Are Disputes and Deductions in Credit Management

Disputes and deductions are a normal part of B2B credit, but they’re also one of the biggest sources of friction, delay, and write-offs. Whether it’s a pricing mismatch, a tax exemption question, missing items, or damage claims, every dispute adds drag to your cash flow and workload.

In a world where credit teams are stretched thin and portfolios keep growing, understanding these issues isn’t optional. It is an essential competency for reducing DSO, maintaining customer trust, and protecting revenue.

This post explains:

• What disputes and deductions actually are
• Why they happen
• How they affect your credit team
• What “good” looks like vs. reactive management
• Why proactive workflows prevent most problems

Article 2 in this series shares the best strategies to manage disputes and deductions successfully.
👉 Read Part Two: Managing Disputes and Deductions Effectively (link).

‍

What Is a Dispute in Credit Management?

A dispute occurs when a customer challenges an invoice before or around the due date. Common reasons include:

• Incorrect pricing
  
• Tax calculation errors
  
• Freight discrepancies
  
• Damaged goods
  
• PO mismatch
  
• Contractual misunderstandings
  

Because disputes surface early, they present a chance to fix problems before an invoice becomes past due. So, why do they matter?

• They slow cash collection if not addressed quickly
  
• They often point to internal process cracks in sales, billing, or fulfillment
  
• They require multi-team collaboration to resolve accurately
  
• They can sour customer relationships when handled poorly
  

A dispute is a signal. It tells you where your process needs tightening.

‍

What Is a Deduction?

A deduction happens when a customer short-pays an invoice without prior notice. In other words, the credit team discovers the issue after the payment arrives.

Here's why deductions are harder:

• The invoice is already past due
  
• You’re playing catch-up to understand what happened
  
• It requires digging through documentation, internal systems, and emails
  
• It often involves multiple departments who weren’t aware of the issue

You and your team may run into common deduction scenarios, such as:

• Unauthorized discounts taken
  
• Damaged goods claims
  
• Rebate disagreements
  
• Pricing misunderstandings
  
• Freight charges
  
• Tax errors
  
• Duplicate invoices
  

A deduction is the credit industry’s version of a mystery. You’re hunting for answers after the fact.

‍

Why Every Credit Team Needs a Dispute/Deduction Protocol

Without structure, disputes and deductions become:

• Time consuming
  
• Emotionally frustrating
  
• Costly
  
• Repetitive
  
• Unpredictable
  

A good protocol improves:

• Accuracy: You know exactly what happened and why.
• Speed: Invoices get resolved before they stall your cash flow.
  
• Customer Relationships: You stay collaborative, not combative.
• Internal Alignment: Sales, credit, finance, logistics, and billing stay on the same page.
  
• DSA and bad-debt exposure: The cleaner your process, the fewer surprises.
  

‍

What Best-In-Class Investigations Look Like

Across credit teams, successful dispute investigation tends to follow the same playbook:

• Get documentation as early as possible. Invoices, quotes, price updates, taxes, delivery records, PODs.
  ‍
• Validate the request. Is the deduction legitimate or not? For example:
  
  • Was the customer quoted one price but billed another?
  • Do you have an active tax exemption on file?
  • If there’s damage, was it your truck or a subcontractor?

• Involve the right parties. This means:
  
  • Sales → pricing context
  • Logistics → delivery issues
  • AR → payment history
  • Legal → contract questions
    ‍
• Keep credit involved until resolution. Even when another team must fix the issue, credit owns the timeline.
  ‍
• Know when to push back or write off. Small-dollar thresholds save time on low-value investigations. Patterns of abuse require deeper review.

‍

The Hidden Cost of Poor Dispute Management

It’s not just a nuisance. Poor dispute handling leads to:

• Slow payments
  
• More deductions in the future
  
• Customer dissatisfaction
  
• Sales friction
  
• Higher write-offs
  
• Longer DSO
  
• Reduced trust in your credit policy
  
  

Every dispute is a chance to strengthen or weaken your credit process.

The Bottom Line

Disputes and deductions aren’t just operational annoyances. They are leading indicators of process health, customer alignment, and credit risk. When credit, sales, and operations collaborate proactively, dispute frequency drops and cash flow improves.

Want to learn the best frameworks to manage disputes successfully?
👉 Read Part Two: The Best Ways to Manage Disputes and Deductions Effectively (link).